Showing posts with label delhi rape case. Show all posts
Showing posts with label delhi rape case. Show all posts

Friday, January 18, 2013

Blame? Accepted . . . Anyone to share

Much has been written, blogged, videographed and talked about the violence that women and girls face in our country. The whole country was sort of having a referendum on what has to be done to prevent such outrageous acts. 



Is it that there has never been violence against women in the pasts? We’ve had worser incidents in the past . . . the most recent being the outraging the modesty of a young lady in the middle of Guwahati city. And before that of 2 young men being slaughtered to death in the middle of Mumbaifor trying to protect few women from being eve-teased. Both the incidents had used the social media to raise awareness. I wonder what progress is being made. 

Over the weeks, many of our politicians and religious leaders have laid bare their intellectual and moral decadence so much that they should have lost at least 50% of their followers. But, I wonder if that has happened.

I wonder so because I am not sure if this is the same thoughts that go through the average Indian’s mind when he thinks about the Indian woman or the girl-child.

In most of our society’s, the birth of a girl child is greeting with a sneer. There is ‘bada khushi’ when a boy is born. No so with the girl. It is seen as a life sentence to the parents to ready her ‘to be a flower in someone’s garden’. Like one of my patients who told me the phrase above. ‘How will I think much about someone who’s not going to adorn my family after a certain age’?

We all know of the countless fetuses which are flushed down the drain of many an obstetrician’s clinic just for the reason that the fetus was a female. Flushing down female fetuses is big time business. It is not unusual to find quacks, nurses and doctor’s assistants do this to make a life.

If she is lucky to be born . . . well and good. Recently someone commented that it would be better for the baby to die before birth as it is too dangerous in India to have a girl child. ‘She may be raped’ ! ! !

Once she is born, the struggle continues. If she is the first child, the parents would be all the more anxious that they have a boy baby soon. And if they do have one within one year, the life of the first girl child is doomed.

She learns to be contented with the leftovers of the food after the male folk have eaten . . . she learns to knit frocks from her mother’s old saris . . . her mother thrusts the knife and vegetables to her hand - - she needs to know cooking well . . . she learns to wake up early in the morning to wash the dishes and give feed to the cattle. . . and then she has go to school - - - because there is free mid-day meal to get there . . . and by evening, she is very tired.

After some time, the family decides that she stops going to school. There are enough dangers on the way . . . and then they should find the ‘garden’ where she settles. Before, she knows anything about her own body, there is a husband waiting for her . . .

Stunted and malnourished, she is soon nurturing another human being in her womb. There is the question pushed to her again. Is it a boy or girl? If it’s a boy . . . great . . . she is going to have a good time.

She learns that boys are better to have than girls . . . and herself prefers to have boys rather than girls. 

I could go on and on . . . Of course, all of the above if she doesn't get raped in between any of the paragraphs. 

And worse when she is harmed by her own, who have been entrusted with her care. 

The question is whether I’m interested in changing all of the above. From the protests we saw in the capital, it looks like there is a genuine interest.

However, I doubt.

Many of us thought that what we saw in the streets of Delhi in repesentative of what India stands for. Dear friends, what we saw in the streets of many of our cities were from India . . . not Bharat. The narration I gave you above is that of Bharat. Chetan Bhagat has  written a interpretation of his on this issue in the Times of India.

I don’t know whether there is less rape in Bharat compared to India. One of our leaders says that Bharat is clean. However, I can vouch for the fact that there is no status for the girl child or the woman in Bharat. To make matters worse, policing and abiding of the law is worse in Bharat.

The ‘Bharatiya Nari’ has no voice. Very similar to the ‘India against corruption’ movement, my fear is that the protests we see against the violence towards women will die down. I wish that does not happen.

However, there is a major vested interests primarily from our politicians who will work against the Bharat becoming educated and developed. They have thrived on illiteracy and poverty to bring themselves on to the pedestals and ivory towers that they occupy.

At least we, Indians, need to realise that there is another group of our own countrymen who have no access to the basic amenities that we Indians enjoy . . . they are the ones . . . who build the metros and the buildings. . . waving at us as we whiz past sleepy villages in the Rajdhanis and Shatabdis . . . selling up goll-guppas and chat on the road . . . clean our roads when all of us sleep . . . even producing the food that we eat.

As we live in mansions, they live in one roomed huts. They eat on a basic diet of rotis, a piece of onion and a slice of chilly while we gorge on burgers and ice-cream. When we seek out branded apparel, they search for some piece of cloth to cover their nakedness and shield from the winter chill .. .. .. Of course, they see the woman as a fixative to help them go on with their lives.

Producing children for their fields, fixing their food and helping them in their fields and work . . . that is the maximum they can think about the girl child and the woman.

Yeah . . . the mentality stays on when they get some sort of development into their lives.  Many of us, Indians have graduated from Bharat. And somewhere along with line we've failed to shake off the superiority complex we've harboured over women. The girl child and the woman is still seen as the helper rather than as a separate individual with her own dreams and wishes.

And the result is violence when the men folk see a change in the perceived role of the women. 

Change is something which is going to be very difficult. Of course, I do not deny the fact that more stringent laws and practical ways of enforcing them needs to get priority. 

Stephen Pinker, a professor of psychology at Harvard has quoted that change came about when women began to assume positions of power and make their interests known. Have not we had enough of women leadership in the country?

But, it has not worked in India.  

The easiest part I can do is to believe that the best place to start a change is me.I need to ensure that I treat women on an equal footing . . . ensure that I give them equal opportunities if not better. I need to ensure that my daughters would be able to develop to the maximum potential . . . I have to teach my son to respect the girls and women around him. 

And of course, the dangerous part . . . which I would better leave untold . . . You could be put in a position to defend a woman at the cost of your life.

I know that this is going to be just a very small contribution from my side to ensure that women are protected . . . but I’m sure that it is worth the effort taken. 

But, the bottom line is going to be about how fast we would be able to take along our fellow countrymen to respect womanhood and treat them as equal partners and stewards . . . and as I had mentioned in my first post on the Delhi incident, the changes have to start at the grassroot level . . . homes, communities, mohallas . . . 

This post is part of the contest Who is to be blamed? on WriteUpCafe.com

Saturday, January 5, 2013

Looking ahead . . . Anxious



The start of 2013 was quite a lot different from the previous years. Many a time, I've wondered why we need to celebrate a day as the start of a New Year. One of my seniors wonders whether there is any meaning in the celebration of the start of New Year. I also agree that it is not much different than any other day of the Year. 

Why was this year different? I've been quite anxious than the previous years.

The major reason is the planned departure of our surgeon, for a 2 year break from NJH. Being a hospital which deals with quite a lot of emergency surgical and obstetric load, a surgeon is a very much needed person in the scheme of things here. We've been searching high and low and praying a lot . . . but, there does not seem to be any breakthrough in getting a new one.

So, that is  the first reason of my anxiety.

The next anxiety that I’ve been having is the increased clinical load of the place and the lack of appropriately trained and dedicated staff. As has been described in previous posts, it is not routine clinical care which has been the most tough . . . the intensive care of patients has been a major area of concern.

In addition to the clinical load, it is the major involvement in Community Health and Development by NJH which gives me quite anxious movements. The same reasons . . . we are yet to find the complete team for giving leadership to the projects.

There is major opportunities for both clinical care as well as community health and development. And there is hardly any quality work that is happening in anything.

Few of us were discussing the other day on the possibilities here. A small hospital in a 25 acre campus catering to the secondary and probably tertiary care requirements of a radius of almost 100 kilometers is big opportunity. Pediatrics . . . Internal Medicine . . . Orthopedics . . . it’s only people who we need.

If there was one dream for me in the beginning of 2013, it would be that of more qualified and dedicated staff joining our team. It would be a great pleasure to have more people to share our 'foolishness' of trying to live out  life in this place. The only assurance I can give is that of a life which would bring blessings into the countless number of people around us. Nothing more . . . nothing less.

As I sat penning this mail, I received a call from a friend of mine. Recently, his sister was being evaluated for a very benign looking swelling of her neck. The final diagnosis was out . . . she had leukemia. All my anxieties looked minuscule in comparison to the crisis that this family was in.

She is getting treatment at one of the best centres for cancer treatment. I request prayers for this young lady . . . Her name is Rinsu Susan George.

As we in the medical profession rush for higher degrees and recognition, please remember that the world of our patients are in another realm of things. In places such as ours, there are patients who die because of the absence of very basic medical care. Or they die because they are too poor to access appropriate care.

On the other side, there are people like my friend whose lives come to a standstill because of a serious illness in the family. Many a time, we do not have an answer on why such good people go through such a tough time.

To make matters worse in this world of ours, there are events like the Delhi rape case which sends shudders through each of us.

In a time of such anxieties, my only prayer for the New Year would be that all of us would remain true to St.Peter’s exhortation to cast all our anxieties on Him (The Holy Bible, 1st Peter: 5:7) who gives everlasting life (The Holy Bible, John: 4:1-42) and to believe that God is good and his gracious love is eternal (The Holy Bible, Psalm: 106:1, 107:1, 118:1, 136:1). 

Wednesday, January 2, 2013

The Fourth Estate . . . Quo Vadis


It was quite surprising that Mr. Shashi Tharoor was again on centre-stage all over in almost all media circles yesterday night. The reason . . . he had posted something on Twitter regarding the Delhi rape victim. 

Yesterday night, the way the story was reported, showcased Mr. Tharoor as an uninformed ignorant person with ulterior motive. However today morning, with the family having obviously given it's consent for the same, most of the newspapers have backtracked and have been sort of commending the idea. This is a good article on how the media handled this

The whole incident shows how thoughtless are our media and politicians. We under-estimate the capability of a person who was an illustrious diplomat and was in the running for the UN Secretary General whereas we are ready to accept statements of people who end up apologising most of the time that they were misquoted. We would rather get along with people who would state what we want to hear rather than hear someone who talks from one's heart with conviction. 

And the media just waits to pounce on things. Everyone wants masala so that their viewers or readers would increase. The number of newspapers and news channels who publish real news are on the constant decline. 

Well, it's not in the national scenario that media does not behave with responsibility. 

In my routine clinical practice, it is quite often that I hear about patients threatening to call the 'patrakar' (the local journalist). I ask them to go ahead. During my first year here, there were few who tried to publish news against the hospital. However, when I convinced the local patrakars that they could end up in serious trouble if they published baseless news, they've left me alone. 

One of the common practices in this part of the country is 'paid-news'. If you run an NGO, it is very common for you to call the 'patrakar' and give him a 'baksheesh'. The prominence, the news about your program will command is directly proportional to how much you pay. 

I made a conscious effort to ensure that these guys are not called when we have big programs in the hospital. However, there is one problem. When we call some of the big shots in the government or administration, they usually ask where the patrakar is? I politely tell them that we usually don't invite the patrakar separately. However, they end up calling them up and they usually rush to cover the event. 

Even, with this Delhi rape case . . . although I'm quite encouraged by the protests it could muster and the awareness people got after the media coverage. I wonder .. .. .. is it that we never had molestation against women? In fact, 2 young men (Keenan Santos and Reuben Fernandes) were killed in Mumbai when they went to protest against a young lady being molested. To make matters worse, I read that there were about 25 cases of reported molestations against women since the Delhi rape all over the country. However, you were not interested in following them the same way you reported this particular incident. 

My dear friends . . . in the light of such incidents and experiences that we've had with the media, I propose that nobody of us believe much on what they say and publish. 

And my friends in the media . . . there is something called ethics which you need to follow. Please remember that you are not the rule enforcers or the judiciary. Your role is to report what happened . . . and not to report what you think should/would have happened . . . or not to report what you are paid to report. 

And please do remember . . . there is another India, news about which does not make find many takers. Hope you remember the Banwari Devi case. I wonder why much fuss was not made for that poor lady. There are many more which go unreported . . . 

Hope that you would be a voice for the voiceless rather than an amplifier which decides when to switch itself on or how loud and clear one should sound. 

Wish you'll report with sense and responsibility in 2013. Happy New Year . . .